Chapter 16, Section 19
Part of AM Radio Facts and Trivia: The AM Broadcast Band in the USA. Updated November 15, 2026.
Radio comedy has a fair claim to being the most influential comedy in American history: in barely a decade it rewrote the country's sense of humor. And it pulled off a trick no one has matched since: it did sight gags on a medium with no sight. The overstuffed closet that buried Fibber McGee in an avalanche of junk, Jack Benny's wheezing Maxwell jalopy, a ventriloquist's dummy: you never saw any of it, and that was the point. Each listener painted the picture privately, so a single joke landed in millions of slightly different versions, coast to coast.
Ranked by ratings and lasting influence, radio's five greatest comedies:
| # | Show | On the Air | What Made It Matter |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Jack Benny Program | 1932-1955 | Radio's #1 comedy for two decades; the eternally-39 cheapskate whose biggest laugh was a pause |
| 2 | Edgar Bergen & Charlie McCarthy | 1937-1956 | A ventriloquist as a radio superstar: the medium's perfect absurdity |
| 3 | Fibber McGee and Molly | 1935-1959 | Wistful Vista, the overstuffed hall closet, and "'Taint funny, McGee" |
| 4 | Amos 'n' Andy | 1928-1960 | A national obsession that shaped the sitcom, and a racial caricature voiced by two white men |
| 5 | Burns and Allen | 1934-1950 | George and Gracie's double act: "Say good night, Gracie" |
Table 16.19-1
Honorable mentions: The Fred Allen Show (and its mock feud with Benny), The Bob Hope Show, The Red Skelton Show, The Great Gildersleeve, and Our Miss Brooks.
The supreme example sat at number two. Edgar Bergen was a ventriloquist (an act built entirely on not catching the performer's lips move) and he became one of the biggest stars in all of radio, a medium where no one could see his lips at all. It didn't matter, because the trick was never the point; the point was Charlie McCarthy, the saucy, top-hatted dummy whose insolence Bergen voiced. Audiences didn't tune in to be fooled. They tuned in for a personality who happened to be made of wood.
At the very top stood Jack Benny, radio's number-one comedian for the better part of two decades. His genius was a character (the impossibly vain, perpetually 39-year-old skinflint) and his single most famous laugh was a silence: held up at gunpoint and ordered "Your money or your life!", Benny let the pause stretch and stretch until the audience was howling, then snapped, "I'm thinking it over!" He also ran a years-long "feud" with fellow comedian Fred Allen that both men entirely invented and the whole country happily played along with.
And then there is the show that out-drew them all and is the hardest to celebrate. Amos 'n' Andy was a national obsession in the early 1930s: a nightly serial so popular it is often credited with inventing the situation comedy and selling a generation of radio sets. It was also a minstrel act: two white performers, Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll, voicing Black characters in broad dialect, a caricature protested in its own day and largely withdrawn from circulation in the decades since. You cannot tell the story of radio comedy without it, nor tell that story honestly without saying plainly what it was. When television came, the rest of the giants simply walked across: Benny, Burns and Allen, the spun-off Great Gildersleeve, but radio comedy's real monument stayed behind, invisible: the millions of private pictures it painted in the dark.
Sources: jimramsburg "All-Time Top 100" & otrcat ratings-by-year; PBS Make 'Em Laugh (radio); Wikipedia (Fred Allen and the individual shows).
© 2026 Chris, N6JET. Free to read and share for non-commercial use with credit (Creative Commons BY-NC 4.0). Not for sale.
All AM radio stories by subject · AM radio interactive tools and simulators · AM Trivia Challenge quiz